The great Guru hoax: Parts 1 and 2 


Autumn 2003

The great Guru hoax: Part 1

By 1977, Srila Prabhupada had built ISKCON into a confederation of many dozens of temples, farm communities and restaurants, and accepted 10,000 disciples. He had also authored dozens of books of spiritual knowledge of which over 150 million had been distributed in all the major languages of the world. Shortly before his passing, he issued a directive to all ISKCON centres and ISKCON Governing Body Commissioners (the senior managers running the movement), to be implemented immediately in ISKCON.

The directive, sets out a system by which Srila Prabhupada would continue to accept disciples without the need for him to be on the scene. As you will read in the directive, he names 11 senior secretaries who were entrusted with accepting new recruits into the movement as direct disciples of Srila Prabhupada. The directive clearly states:

"The newly initiated devotees are disciples of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, the above eleven senior devotees acting as His representative."

However, shortly after Srila Prabhupada's departure in November 1977, the GBC audaciously announced that the 11 secretaries had actually been selected as full-fledged Gurus or spiritual masters, and were to accept disciples themselves, and thus replace Srila Prabhupada in this capacity. This of course is in complete contradiction to the directive, wherein it is clearly stated that the 11 secretaries had been selected to remain in a representational capacity to accept disciples FOR Srila Prabhupada. The official 1978 GBC minutes, not widely seen till now, clearly document this hoax in black and white:

"…for 1978, no new Spiritual Masters shall be appointed other than the 11 selected by Srila Prabhupada."
(GBC Resolutions No.16, March 19th,1978)

These 11 self-appointed 'Gurus' then immediately carved the world up into 11 zones and began accepting daily, lavish worship on huge, ornate thrones (known as Vyasasanas). They labelled themselves the 'material and spiritual successors' to Srila Prabhupada, and under the pretence of this hoax funneled huge amounts of disciples and money to themselves. Soon, however, the pretence of living a blatant lie began to catch up with them. Virtually all of these original disobedient secretaries descended into an abyss of moral degradation barely befitting a normal human being, what to speak of a Guru.

The Senior Deviators: Where are they now?

Kirtanananda: Left ISKCON after being caught engaging in illicit activity. Currently in prison for racketeering.
Harikesha: Ran off with his female massage therapist and cash. Now married and enjoying cash.
Ramesvara: Left ISKCON after being caught engaging in illicit activity. Now working in real estate.
Jayatirtha: Left ISKCON to start his own LSD drug cult, and had his head hacked off by one of his followers in a drug-induced attack.
Bhavananda: Left ISKCON after being caught engaging in illicit activity. Now trying to re-enter the movement in Australia.
Hansadutta: Left ISKCON after being caught engaging in illicit activity. Later confessed to the 'Guru hoax' and lives today as an ordinary devotee.
Tamal Krishna: Told many different stories to justify 'Guru hoax' before dying horribly in a car crash.
Bhagavan: Left ISKCON after being caught engaging in illicit activity. Later imprisoned and now hanging out on the fringe of the movement.
Hridayananda: Went back to college to get education. Still acting as 'Guru'.
Jayapataka: Under police investigation for abetment to suicide. Still acting as 'Guru'.
Satsvarupa: Under medication and in semi- retirement. Still acting as 'Guru'.

As an internal memo written by another self- appointed 'Guru' regarding the antics of these original 11 'Gurus' stated:

"FACT: ISKCON gurus have usurped and misused money, and diverted other ISKCON resources for their own personal prestige and sense gratification. ISKCON gurus have had illicit sexual intercourse with both women and men, and possibly children as well."
('Where the Ritvik People Are Right', Jayadvaita Swami, 1996)

Given the huge embarrassment caused by the horrendous behaviour of these initial guru imposters, one would have thought that most sane, what to speak of spiritual people, would have held up their hands and admitted a terrible wrongdoing had been perpetrated. Unfortunately, instead of doing this, all we got was the great Guru hoax, Part 2.
 

The great Guru hoax: Part 2

By 1986, following the spiritual and moral fall-down of many of the self-appointed impostor 'Gurus', the Governing Body Commission tried to cover-up their initial and highly damaging hoax that led to this state of affairs with yet another hoax.
In order to pacify the movement's members and deflect attention away from their own misdemeanours, they suddenly announced that drastic, sweeping changes did indeed need to be made. But their proposed 'changes' did not entail admitting the original hoax whereby false guruship had been grabbed by individuals who had only been appointed as secretaries. Instead, amazingly, it was announced that not enough self-appointed Gurus had been made in 1978. They decreed that now ANYONE who got a majority vote of the GBC could be made a Guru:

" …any GBC can present a diksa guru candidate before the GBC body. […] and upon majority approval of the body, he may take up the responsibilities of an initiating guru in ISKCON."
(GBC Resolution 3, March 30th, 1986)

And the written authority from Srila Prabhupada for this new 'Guru by vote' hoax? Same as the last one - none. In this way, the unauthorised Gurus in ISKCON have now expanded to almost 80, with the number varying every year as more fall down into moral and spiritual degradation, and more are hurriedly added to replace them.

All the while, this 'Guru mess' has completely side lined the real and only Guru of ISKCON, Srila Prabhupada, who as we have seen authorised that he remain the Guru of ISKCON via representatives who should only act as his agents to accept disciples on his behalf. Unfortunately these representatives decided to hijack the movement for their own ends, creating the chaos we have today.

ISKCON Leaders Reveal Hoax

A hoax by definition has no substance, built as it is on a foundation of lies and fabrication. The Guru hoax reveals itself whenever ISKCON leaders attempt to explain just how the Gurus came into existence. The result is a mass of contradictory accounts about what is meant to be the same event – the alleged ‘authorisation’ by Srila Prabhupada of the ‘Gurus’ to succeed him.

ISKCON Leaders contradict each other and themselves as they try to explain hoax!

Anuttama das, ISKCON’s Director of Communications:

Prabhupada “hand-selected leaders who had been appointed as gurus”

(ISKCON Communications Journal, Vol. 8, No.1, June 2000)
Ravindra Svarupa das,
ISKCON GBC member and elected Guru:

“There was no hand-picking of successors”

(ISKCON Communications Journal, Vol. 2, No.1, January 1994)
Tamal Krishna Goswami (1946-2002):

“Actually Prabhupada never appointed any gurus. He appointed eleven ritviks. He never appointed them gurus”

(Pyramid House, Topanga Canyon, 3 December 1980)
Tamal Krishna Goswami (1946-2002):

“Prabhupada appointed eleven successor gurus... Srila Prabhupada’s successor acaryas”

(‘Servant of the Servant’, pp 361-5, BBT 1984)
Jayadvaita Swami,

ISKCON- elected Guru:

“Srila Prabhupada did not appoint anyone to be guru for the future”
 
(Video, San Diego debate, 1990)
Satsvarupa das Goswami:

“Srila Prabhupada said he will appoint several devotees who shall perform initiation in the future, even after his disappearance. The disciples they accept shall be their disciples.”

(GBC Minutes Book 1977, recorded in GBC paper ‘Prabhupada’s Order’. Satsvarupa das Goswami appears as lead signatory)